The Edmonton Oilers' shortcomings hinder their pursuit of the Stanley Cup

EDMONTON — Newsflash: The Florida Panthers are simply a better team than the Edmonton Oilers. Or at least, they play a better game of Stanley Cup playoff hockey.

Why are the Oilers coughing up pucks every night that end up in their goal, while Florida is not? Because Florida is cleaner in their own zone, and smarter.

Why is Florida scoring three or four goals a night while Edmonton is chasing every game? Because when the Panthers get a chance they get it to the net, while Edmonton button-hooks, passes off and works the perimeter, always searching for the tic-tac-toe goal, and not grinding out the greasy one until far too late in this fatal third game.

The Oilers have solved three teams on the road to this Final. But the Panthers, they’re a puzzle that Edmonton does not seem able to solve.

“We’re trying to figure them out,” said Connor McDavid. “We haven’t beat them in three games, we’ve had stretches of good and stretches of bad… We’re trying to figure them out.”

He and Leon Draisaitl are both without a goal in this series. Draisaitl doesn’t even have a point.

“It’s very frustrating,” Draisaitl said. “I pride myself on being good in the playoffs and playing well, and I just can’t seem to get anything going. Obviously, I have to look in the mirror and try to be better.”

The Oilers hung around a while in Game 3 on a goal by Warren Foegele, but Florida got one hand on their first-ever Stanley Cup with a three-goal outburst in a 6:19 span of the second period. With a 4-1 lead and a dispirited Rogers Place, Florida found the finish line in a 4-3 win.

They’ve won most of the last seven periods of this Cup Final. Win two or three more on Saturday night and the Stanley Cup will be on the ice at Rogers Place. Sadly for the Oilers, the captain taking it from commissioner Gary Bettman will not be McDavid.

“We’re playing in June, and that’s something to be very grateful for,” began goalie Stuart Skinner, who has not been as sharp as the spectacular Sergei Bobrovsky, as if anyone could. “At the same time… it is disappointing being down 3-0. We’ve got to let that reality sink in.

“I’m not too sure what the stats are on coming back from it, but if anyone can do it, it’s the Oil.”

The second-period implosion was something the Oilers had vowed not to re-live after they blew their second-round series against Vegas last spring with a similar meltdown. And they’d been very good at avoiding it thus far.

But the frustration administered by the Panthers was visible on Thursday night, and it exposed an Oilers team that has simply run out of ways to find success against this opponent.

“After they got that second one, they just kind of got on a roll,” Skinner said. “We let them take that momentum and stride with it. They got two more quick ones — just kind of silly mistakes that (don’t) need to happen.”

Apart from the fact that none of McDavid, Draisaitl, Zach Hyman, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins or the vaunted Oilers power play has managed a goal in this series, this series will be remembered locally for mistakes made by Edmonton that were force-fed into their own goal by Florida.

With the score tied at one Thursday, Skinner misplayed a puck behind his goal and was solely responsible for the 2-1 goal. Then Darnell Nurse, in full possession of the biscuit, was stripped.

Boom! It’s 3-1 for Florida.

The Aleksander Barkov breakaway goal that made it 4-1 put the dagger in the Oilers’ Stanley Cup dreams.

“I don’t know,” said Draisaitl. “We’re a good offensive team, we’re doing a good job. We’re still getting our looks. When you’re chasing the game for a big chunk of the night it’s just hard to come back.”

“Two of the three games we’re at or above our (average) expected goals scored,” said head coach Kris Knoblauch. “We’re playing well enough to score goals, putting ourselves in a good enough position to score goals.

“We’ve had more breakaways in these three games than we’ve had through the playoffs. We’re getting our chances.”

The Panthers simply have the recipe to beating Edmonton, from crushing the Oilers on their attempted zone exits to knowing that the path of least resistance is the preferred one by too many Oilers forwards.

Florida is simply a harder, more defensively sound team with better goaltending, deeper scoring depth and structure that is more sound and consistent. And if you manage to get a puck through the near-perfect system played by the Panthers, the guy waiting in their goal is nearly impenetrable.

“Their goalie is playing incredible right now,” Draisaitl said. “You can probably find a way to push a couple more over the goal, and it’s probably a different game. But we just gave up too many. Made too many mistakes.”

The Edmonton Oilers have long been a team with high expectations and a passionate fan base. However, despite having some of the most talented players in the NHL, the team has consistently fallen short in their pursuit of the Stanley Cup. There are several key shortcomings that have hindered the Oilers’ chances of achieving hockey’s ultimate prize.

One of the biggest issues facing the Oilers is their lack of depth beyond their top players. While stars like Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl are among the best in the league, the team struggles to find consistent production from their supporting cast. This lack of secondary scoring puts added pressure on McDavid and Draisaitl to carry the team offensively, making it easier for opponents to shut them down in crucial moments.

Another area of concern for the Oilers is their defensive play. The team has struggled to keep pucks out of their own net, ranking near the bottom of the league in goals against per game. This lack of defensive consistency puts additional pressure on their goaltenders and makes it difficult for the team to win close games.

Additionally, the Oilers have struggled with consistency throughout the season. While they have shown flashes of brilliance at times, they have also gone through extended stretches of poor play. This inconsistency has cost them valuable points in the standings and made it difficult for them to gain momentum heading into the playoffs.

Finally, coaching and management decisions have also played a role in the Oilers’ shortcomings. While head coach Dave Tippett has had success in the past, there have been questions about his ability to get the most out of this talented roster. Additionally, general manager Ken Holland has made some questionable moves in terms of player personnel and roster construction, which have not always paid off.

In order for the Edmonton Oilers to overcome these shortcomings and make a serious run at the Stanley Cup, they will need to address these issues head-on. This may involve making changes to their roster, coaching staff, or management structure. Regardless of the path they choose, it is clear that the Oilers will need to make significant improvements in order to compete with the top teams in the league and finally bring a championship back to Edmonton.