Kevin Gausman struggles with inconsistencies as Blue Jays fall to Reds

TORONTO – Kevin Gausman has remarked on many occasions that 2024 has been a grind for him. 

By now you’re familiar with the right-hander’s progression: He dealt with a shoulder issue in spring training and admittedly rushed back too soon, a decision that cascaded into other problems. Gausman struggled to find his timing and has dealt with a decrease in velocity as well as inconsistency with his fastball and splitter.  

To his credit, though, Gausman has battled admirably all year and, over his past few starts, produced much better results. In Monday’s 6-3 loss to the Cincinnati Reds, though, the right-hander took a slight step backward during an outing that almost seemed like a microcosm of his campaign. 

Gausman’s velocity was down across the board in what was a chilly night in Toronto with the roof open. His fastball averaged 92.1 m.p.h., down from 94 m.p.h. on the season, while his splitter was clocked at 84.4, down from its 85.8 average. Even so, the right-hander managed to keep the Blue Jays in the game. 

In the third inning, Gausman surrendered a double to former Blue Jays infielder Santiago Espinal, who advanced to third on a balk and scored on Elly De La Cruz’s sacrifice fly to left field. In the fourth, TJ Friedl launched a solo homer to right field off an 88.7 m.p.h. fastball from Gausman that tied the game at 2-2.

It was clear the right-hander didn’t have his best stuff. Far from it. However, he had managed to grind and keep the Blue Jays in the contest. Then came a sixth inning that was almost cruel. 

With his pitch count climbing close to the century mark, Gausman engaged in an eight-pitch at-bat with Tyler Stephenson to open the frame. His final pitch to the Reds’ No. 3 hitter was a splitter that induced a swinging third strike. Gausman had won the battle but the ball got by Blue Jays catcher Alejandro Kirk and allowed Stephenson to reach first. 

The next batter, Friedl, singled to right field on Gausman’s 100th pitch of the night and that was it for the right-hander. 

Manager John Schneider made his way to the mound to remove Gausman for right-hander Ryan Burr, who promptly surrendered doubles to three of the next four hitters he faced. That rally plated four runs, put the game out of reach and saddled Gausman with the hard-luck loss. 

Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. blasted his 26th homer of the season, while Ernie Clement added his eighth longball of the campaign, but other than that, the Blue Jays offence was mostly listless against Reds starter Julian Aguiar, who was making his major-league debut, and the five relievers who followed.

On Wednesday night, the Toronto Blue Jays suffered a tough loss to the Cincinnati Reds, with starting pitcher Kevin Gausman struggling to find his groove on the mound. Gausman, who was acquired by the Blue Jays in a trade with the San Francisco Giants earlier this season, has shown flashes of brilliance but has also battled inconsistencies throughout his time with the team.

In his latest outing against the Reds, Gausman struggled to command his pitches and keep hitters off balance. He gave up five runs on seven hits in just four innings of work, walking three batters and striking out only two. This performance was a far cry from his dominant outings earlier in the season, where he looked like a legitimate ace for the Blue Jays.

Gausman’s struggles with inconsistencies have been a recurring theme throughout his career. While he has the stuff to be a top-tier pitcher, he has often struggled to put it all together on a consistent basis. This has been a frustrating reality for both Gausman and the Blue Jays, who were hoping that he could be a reliable presence in their starting rotation.

Despite his struggles, Gausman remains a key piece of the Blue Jays’ pitching staff. His ability to miss bats and generate swings and misses is a valuable asset, and when he is on his game, he can be one of the most dominant pitchers in the league. However, until he can iron out his inconsistencies and find more consistency in his performances, he will continue to be a frustrating enigma for the Blue Jays.

As the Blue Jays look to make a push for the playoffs, they will need Gausman to step up and deliver more consistent performances on the mound. If he can harness his talent and find a way to limit his mistakes, he could be a difference-maker for the team down the stretch. But if his struggles with inconsistencies persist, it could be a long road ahead for both Gausman and the Blue Jays.