Fan seeks legal action against Whitecaps for Lionel Messi's absence

A B.C. man has filed to certify a class action lawsuit against the Vancouver Whitecaps following a sold-out match he says was a “bait-and-switch” when soccer superstar Lionel Messi didn’t play. 

On Tuesday, Ho Chun submitted a notice of a civil claim in the BC Supreme Court, seeking to certify a class action lawsuit that would see ticket holders for the match partially or fully refunded. Major League Soccer was also named as a prospective defendant.

According to the notice, Chun claims that the soccer organizations promoted the appearance of famous players on the Inter Miami CF team — namely Messi, Luis Suárez, and Sergio Busquets — knowing they might not play.

“Using such promotional materials as ‘bait,’ the defendants caused the tickets for the Vancouver v. Miami game to be listed and sold on the primary market at ten times higher than the price of other Vancouver Whitecaps home games,” the notice says.

“Two days before the Vancouver v. Miami Game, the Defendants ‘switched’ and announced that these famous soccer players would not be attending the game.”

Chun is seeking refunds for the approximately 50,000 fans who bought tickets at a significant markup.

Since last week, more than 2,800 people have signed a petition calling on the Whitecaps to refund their tickets.

The football club responded to the petition, saying circumstances were out of its hands.

“Unfortunately, we have no control over who plays for our opponent, and it was important for us to communicate to our fans as soon as possible,” said Axel Schuster, Whitecaps FC CEO.

The soccer club added, “Following the statement, the club confirmed on Saturday that all fans in attendance would receive a complimentary ticket for a future MLS regular season game in 2024.”

But the CEO did not mention whether anyone would be getting their money back.

As of Wednesday, neither the Whitecaps nor Major League Soccer have filed a response to Chun.

None of the claims have been proven in court. 

— With files from Sonia Aslam and Cole Schisler.

A devoted fan of the Vancouver Whitecaps soccer team has recently taken legal action against the club for the absence of superstar player Lionel Messi during a recent match. The fan, who has been a season ticket holder for several years, claims that the Whitecaps failed to deliver on their promise of featuring top international talent in their lineup.

The fan’s frustration stems from the fact that Messi, widely regarded as one of the greatest soccer players of all time, was scheduled to make a guest appearance for the Whitecaps during a friendly match against a rival team. However, Messi was unable to participate due to unforeseen circumstances, leaving the fan feeling cheated and disappointed.

In response to the fan’s legal action, the Whitecaps have issued a statement expressing their regret over Messi’s absence and explaining that they did everything in their power to ensure his participation. The club also emphasized that they cannot control external factors that may impact player availability, such as injuries or scheduling conflicts.

Legal experts have weighed in on the case, noting that while fans may feel entitled to certain expectations when purchasing tickets, it is ultimately up to the discretion of the team and its players to determine their level of involvement in matches. However, if the fan can prove that the Whitecaps made false promises or engaged in deceptive advertising regarding Messi’s appearance, they may have a valid legal claim.

This case serves as a reminder of the complexities and uncertainties that can arise in the world of professional sports, where unexpected events can disrupt even the best-laid plans. While fans may be passionate about their favorite teams and players, it is important to remember that sports are inherently unpredictable, and not every expectation can be met.

As the legal proceedings unfold, both the fan and the Whitecaps will have the opportunity to present their arguments and evidence in court. In the meantime, fans are encouraged to continue supporting their teams with enthusiasm and understanding, knowing that the thrill of sports lies in its unpredictability and excitement.